Wed 27 Sep 2006
Credit Card Arbitrage – A Win-Win for Banks
Posted by RichSlick under Easy money
Thanks for visiting. This Blog and is intended for individuals with Net Annual Income of $105,000 or more. Get Rich Slow + Get Rich Quick = Get Rich Slick. If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed.
As some of you know, I took out a 24k loan from my credit card at 0%. The zero rate was only for 6 months so I took the money and placed it in a high yield CD earning 8%. The gross profit on this transaction will be about about $1200.
The 0% rate runs out in December and I was planning on opening a new credit card account and transfer the balance to another 0% card but I recently received my credit card statement and lo and behold there more 0% checks to extend it another 6 months.
I’ll hold off on opening a new account and hold off using the checks until late October or early November but this “generosity” from the credit card bank got me thinking as to why they do it.
The common wisdom is that banks offer 0% as a teaser and simply wait for you to default so they can pop the rate to 25% or more but I’m not convinced this is the whole story.
Banks have sophisticated credit models to know how likely a person is to default on their credit. With me, personally, I have been doing business with this particular bank for years and have NEVER been late nor will I ever be. This partially explains why they have given me higher and higher credit limits.
My suspicion is that banks KNOW that a certain number of their customers are doing Arbitrage deals and THEY benefit more from it than we do. How?
With the advent of “fractional reserve banking” bank can lend out 90-99% of the money in their accounts out as loans.
So let’s take a look at how my particular transaction would work:
Credit Card lends me $25,000 at 0% (they know I’ll pay them back so it’s relatively risk free)
I take $25,000 and deposit it at Emigrant earning 5.15% (I earn ~ $1300)
Emigrant takes $25,000 in as a deposit and can lend out $25,000 at say 10% interest (more credit card loans) and accumulates $25,000 in interest from those loans.
This turns into a win-win for banks. On the one hand, they have the potential to earn 25%+ interest on a credit card loan of 25k if I default and on the other hand, they have the ability to lend out 10 times the amount it has on deposits courtesy of my deposit.
It seems to me that banks can truly optimize their returns and profit if they can find people like me that will arbitrage their own money back into their accounts. We’ll see which one does it first.

























September 27th, 2006 at 9:56 am
Would this not assume though that the banks are in collusion together? How does Citi make money when Emigrant loans out your 0% BT funds? Very few banks are as generous as Citi is with the BT offers; most at the very least still charge a transfer fee. And Citi’s on-line savings acct is pretty weak compared to Emigrante/HSBC, meaning that people savvy enough to do arbitrage probably don’t put it into the CitiBank On-line savings accounts…
I could of course be missing something, but it seems to me that Citi and others like them just have too much money and are looking for ways to put it to work with even the slightest chance of a better-than-T-Bills return.
September 27th, 2006 at 12:09 pm
Good points but the easiest way I can think of how they benefit is through the endless merger and acquisition.
Chase bought out Bank One
Bank of America swallowed Fleet
Bank of America swallowed MBNA
There are so many click here to see others:
http://www.answers.com/topic/list-of-bank-mergers-in-united-states
Almost every year there are constant mergers and acquisitions
As for the banks being in collusion, they are to an extent in collusion with the federal reserve to control the money supply.
I believe the largest banks (Chase, Citibank, BoA, etc) are all members/owners of the Federal Reserve but that part is kept secret so I can’t be sure…